Late
Sunday night, a terrible reminder a national tragedy was thrust
before my eyes. I was flipping through the channels about 10:45pm
when I saw the Michael Moore's film “Bowling for Columbine,”
which was released in October 2002, had just begun. I had missed just
the first few minutes but immediately hit the record button and gave
it my full attention until I fell asleep a little after midnight.
When I
got up this morning, I turned on my DVR and watched the film in its
entirety. The heart wrenching images of young people dying at the
hands of other young people, including the Columbine massacre and the
accidental shooting of one 6 year old child by another 6 year old
child brought tears to my eyes. The source of these tears was both
despair and rage, because juxtaposed against the searing images was
footage of Charlton Heston, president of the NRA, holding rallies in
both locations, as bad luck would have it, just days after these
tragedies occurred. His apparent indifference and lack of insight
into the scope of the problem he helps to promote had me cursing at
my TV.
At one
point in the movie, Mr. Moore makes an excellent point by showing how
young people all over the world are exposed to the same sort of
ritualized and glorified violence as American youth. Yet worldwide
murder statistics demonstrate how the United States is far and away
the most violent first world nation on earth. The numbers cited were
startling. In other first world countries, the highest number he
could find was in Germany where there were 381murders committed with
a gun. The exact year is not clear. The lowest number was in Japan,
where there were just 39 murders committed with a gun. Then he shows
the number for the US: 11,127 murders committed with a gun in one
year. The stark difference speaks volumes about the culture of
violence and fear that has been fostered by the media and reinforced
by the government.
After it
was over and I was channel flipping again, just by chance I came upon
a show called Vanguard which was doing an expose on gun violence in
America. This program was released in 2009 and followed a reporter to
two locations. The first was in Kentucky where supporters of gun
ownership proudly showed off their hardware and declared themselves
real Americans who were doing nothing more than exercising their
second Amendment rights. The second location was Camden NJ, which has
several times been declared the most dangerous city in America. It
showed how the easy availability of guns has created a massive law
enforcement problem and devastated the local economy.
I looked
at Wikipedia and saw how Mr. Moore's film had received multiple
accolades upon its release and then I thought about the fact that
although it had won all these awards, it had not changed the world at
all. We are still bombarded nightly with example after example of
brutal violence and the reinforcement of the culture of fear.
So I
decided to do a little digging to see if maybe things had changed for
the worse in other parts of the world, with the notion that maybe
economic hardship had made people in other parts of the world more
violent.
But my
theory was not supported by the evidence. In five minutes I was able
to find the following numbers. In 2009, the number of gun murders in
the US, according to the FBI, fell to 10,224. The number of gun
murders in Japan for the same year? Seven. In the United Kingdom the
number is 63 and in Germany, 381, the exact same number as Mr. Moore
cites.
So while
the 5% drop in the number of gun murders may give me a slight reason
to feel encouraged, the numbers from the rest of the world still
prove that the US is a far more violent place to live and ten years
after Mr. Moore's film slapped us in the face, we still haven't
awakened to face the reality.
Mr.
Moore's film made one very salient point to answer the question of
why America is so violent. Fear keeps people consuming. Consumption
is a large part of the American economy. This is the status quo and
some very powerful people profit from the status quo. Those powerful
people make a lot of political contributions. Think about that the
next time the network news shows footage of a child shot dead in the
street.